# AI assistant answer scorecard prompt: free ChatGPT template > A prompt that checks four AI assistants' answers to the same task against your own facts and fills a scorecard, so you can pick one for work. Source: https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/prompts/ai-assistant-answer-scorecard-prompt · Updated 2026-10-16 · Free from Stepthrough (https://learn.ynteractive.com) [Reports and planning](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/prompts#job-reports-and-planning) · [Operations](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/prompts#industry-operations) · Works in ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Copilot Updated October 16, 2026 · By [Robert Breen](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/about) Use this after you give one real office task to ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Copilot, and you want a fair, boring comparison on facts instead of an opinion. Paste your source facts and the four answers, and the AI builds the scorecard. The scorecard is a first check, not a verdict. Open the source yourself and confirm anything marked wrong, and remember that the plan your company pays for decides which assistant you may use at work. ## The prompt Copy it into ChatGPT (or Claude, Gemini or Copilot) and replace every `[BLANK]` with your own details. It uses the four parts from [Prompt Writing 101](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/prompt-writing-101-role-context-task-format): Role, Context, Task and Format. Copy prompt ```text Role: You are a careful reviewer comparing answers from four AI assistants to the same task for [BUSINESS]. Context: The task was: [TASK]. The facts the answers must match are: [FACTS]. The four answers follow, labelled A to D: [ANSWERS]. Task: For each answer, check each fact and write Correct, Wrong or Missing, with a one-line reason. Also list anything the answer added that I did not ask for. Do not decide which assistant is best. Do not invent facts that are not in the source. Format: A table with one row per answer and one column per fact, then a short list of added extras per answer. End with two questions I should answer before choosing one for work. ``` ## Fill in the blanks **`[BUSINESS]`** Your firm or team name. **`[TASK]`** The exact task you gave all four assistants. **`[FACTS]`** The three to five facts that must appear correctly, such as a date or a phone number. **`[ANSWERS]`** The four answers, pasted one after another and labelled A to D. ## Example, filled in **A made-up example** from the free lesson [Choose the AI Assistant Your Team Should Use, Tested on ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Copilot](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/chatgpt-vs-claude-vs-gemini-vs-copilot-same-task). Ridgeline Insurance Agency is the made-up firm in the Choose the AI Assistant Your Team Should Use lesson. The facts and task below are an illustration, not the lesson's exact data. Copy example ```text Role: You are a careful reviewer comparing answers from four AI assistants to the same task for Ridgeline Insurance Agency. Context: The task was: write a short renewal reminder email to a client and a table of this week's five tasks, Monday to Friday. The facts the answers must match are: the renewal date, the request for the VIN, the office phone number and five task rows in day order. The four answers follow, labelled A to D: [paste the four answers here]. Task: For each answer, check each fact and write Correct, Wrong or Missing, with a one-line reason. Also list anything the answer added that I did not ask for. Do not decide which assistant is best. Do not invent facts that are not in the source. Format: A table with one row per answer and one column per fact, then a short list of added extras per answer. End with two questions I should answer before choosing one for work. ``` ## What a good answer looks like - Each answer is scored fact by fact, so the result is not a gut feeling. - Extras the assistant added, such as a tip or a signature line, are listed for you to review. - The AI leaves the choice to you and asks what you still need to decide. ## How to check it before you use it An AI draft can sound right and still say something you never told it. Use the habit from the [Reply Faster lesson](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/chatgpt-reply-to-customer-emails): check every promise, name, date and number against what you gave it before anything goes out. - Check every Wrong or Missing mark against the source yourself. - Do not paste real client data into any assistant you are only testing. Use a harmless task. - Choose the assistant your company already pays for and allows, not only the top scorer. - Run the test again next quarter. Products change. ## Why this prompt works On an everyday task the four big assistants tend to get the facts right and differ in style, so a scorecard on facts shows what really separates them. Asking the AI not to pick a winner keeps the decision with the person who knows the company rules. ## Practice it in the free lesson **[Choose the AI Assistant Your Team Should Use, Tested on ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Copilot](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/chatgpt-vs-claude-vs-gemini-vs-copilot-same-task)**: Give one real office task to ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Microsoft Copilot, check each answer on the facts, and pick the one to use at work. You do every step yourself in a practice copy of ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Copilot, and nothing touches your real accounts. [Start the free lesson](https://learn.ynteractive.com/modules/four-assistants-same-task) Also useful: [Use AI at Work Without Leaking Client Data using ChatGPT](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/safe-ai-at-work-what-not-to-paste) ## Terms used here [AI assistant](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/glossary/ai-assistant) · [Microsoft Copilot](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/glossary/microsoft-copilot) · [AI scorecard](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/glossary/ai-test-scorecard) ## Related prompts - [Software tool evaluation scorecard prompt](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/prompts/software-tool-evaluation-scorecard-prompt): Compare two or three software tools against your own must-haves and nice-to-haves, with each vendor claim marked "verify on… - [Vendor quote comparison prompt](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/prompts/vendor-quote-comparison-prompt): Compare vendor quotes side by side on price, what's included, timing and warranty, with "Not in quote" for gaps and the… - [Sheet question and total checker prompt](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/prompts/spreadsheet-question-checker-prompt): Ask an AI agent about a spreadsheet and make it show its rows, so you can add the numbers yourself before you repeat a total to… ## More reports and planning prompts - [AI pilot plan prompt](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/prompts/ai-pilot-plan-prompt): Plan a small, time-boxed trial of an AI tool: one task, a few people, success criteria you choose up front, how you'll measure… - [AR aging summary prompt](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/prompts/ar-aging-summary-prompt): Turn an accounts receivable aging report into a one-page summary for the owner: what is overdue, who owes the most, and which… - [Automation candidates prompt](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/prompts/automation-candidates-prompt): Rank your repetitive tasks by which to automate first, using only your own counts and minutes, with a first workflow sketched… ## Frequently asked questions **Which assistant should I use at work?** The one your company already pays for and allows, as the free lesson explains. A Microsoft 365 office would use Copilot Chat and a Google Workspace office would use Gemini. **Can one assistant check another's answers?** It can, but it can also make mistakes. Treat the scorecard as a first pass and verify the marks against your source. [All free prompt templates](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/prompts) · [AI glossary](https://learn.ynteractive.com/content/glossary)